| wyndycty |
|
| Jokers Wild |
|
| Reged: 08/09/07 |
| Posts: 104454 |
| Loc: Austin via Chicago by way of Pittsburgh |
|
|
 Survivor 51 recap: Defending the Tribal Council cowards Why the terrible-looking capitulation is super embarrassing, yet strategically correct.…
10/22/26 06:19 AM
|
|
|
|
|
Excerpt…
“So let’s now get into the math of it. No way Kilby was going to flip his vote because he just made his stand, and no matter how much everyone was promising him they would work with him moving forward, that felt about as real as Elizabeth Holmes telling Nathan Fielder she had never told a white lie in her entire life. If Kilby flipped, he’d be the next to go after Lewis.
But Eric, Sharonda, and Cristian were in no such danger. Because even if they capitulated — and make no mistake, they would capitulate in one of the most embarrassing displays ever — they would still go back to camp in a 3-2 majority. Is that worth risking your game over? From a strictly strategic risk vs. reward perspective… mayyyyyyyybe? But probably not.
If the former Savu-strong folks go to rocks, guess what? There is still a 75 percent chance one of them goes home anyway, because they are picking three out of the four rocks. So why risk immediate elimination on a non-game-changing vote with 75 percent odds you lose an alliance-partner anyway when you can guarantee your own safety and still go back to camp in the majority?
So I am not going to sit here and say that it was a bad move for Eric, Sharonda, and Cristian to refuse to go to rocks. It was not a bad move. But it was a bad look.
See, this is reason number 5,748 why I would never, ever go on reality television. I mean, we’ll see how it all plays out down the line, but without being too results-oriented, I do honestly think in the moment what Eric, Sharonda, and Cristian did in leaving their rock-solid ally (slight pun intended) Linnea out to dry because they were too chicken to go to rocks is the right strategic call. But you have to come off looking like a complete coward in doing it.
REALITY TV IS SO MEAN! The move makes the Savu three look so gutless and spineless for folding faster than my beloved Washington Commanders before an overtime field goal attempt. They showed no grit. No moxie. No pluck. No anything from any words that have not been used in popular parlance since the 1940s. But again… I think they made the right call! And this is coming from the ultimate go-to-rocks guy.
The most brutal part about it is that players are very aware out there of how their game will perceived by viewers. Kilby’s no dummy. He is a super fan of the show and he definitely knows in the moment how heroic and badass this will make him appear on TV, which pushes him to stand firm. Conversely, Eric, Sharonda, and Cristian were absolutely aware of how bad Kilby’s resolve and their capitulation would make them look. Not only did they allow their wills to get bulldozed by a single player, but they also completely left their ally Linnea out to dry — not even bothering to risk a rock draw to save her.
The price for them to all make the right strategic decision in that moment was to have to look timid and terrible doing it, and they paid that price indeed. Super fascinating.”
https://ew.com/survivor-51-recap-episode-5-defending-tribal-council-cowards-12186067
|
|
|
|
|
|
