Forums >> Survivor >> Survivor Discussion


This is a response to: The reason it was Michaela and not Cerie is as simple as Michaela can win immunity and Cerie can't... so you can vote out Cerie next week. NT
KlausHeissler
Joker Uber Member
Reged: 08/16/13
Posts: 24317
i know a lot are saying they didnt get why she went instead of Cirie but my first thought when her name was showing up in votes was exactly that. i
05/20/17 10:36 PM




didnt think there was really much more than that tbh.

Entire thread (Refresh)
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Best exit interview I have found by Josh Wigler with Michaela>>>she explains things for us!
Mazita
05/20/17 09:28 AM
xx * After hearing her answers to what went down...it's making me like Michaela a lot more then I did before :) NT
SkyBluePink
05/20/17 08:42 PM
xx * To me after reading it, she seems like the same old Michaela. After seeing her tell Brad to go fish, I think I know why people did not talk to her. NT
Hidef1080
05/20/17 11:07 PM
xx * I was reading through the interview thinking this person sounded so likable compared to the show Michaela, but that was when she was talking
krh5038
05/20/17 08:48 PM
xx * As Long As She Stays True To Her Word And Doesn't Come Back Until She Is 35 I Can Live With That. NT
Axelsen
05/20/17 08:59 PM
xx * She's OK until she turns into the OTHER Michaela. :-) NT
JAF
05/20/17 08:44 PM
xx * I didn't see last season, but that would probably really hurt to punch a tree. NT
krh5038
05/20/17 06:52 PM
xx * Good interview and breakdown. US Survivor's editing is on the decline, can Michaela edit these episodes because she makes more sense than the edit.
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 02:37 PM
xx * I don't think sensical is exactly what they're going for on the edit. NT
krh5038
05/20/17 06:50 PM
xx * I don't think Sarah had the elaborate plan to test Cerie... I think she was shocked when Cerie tried to use... and never expected Cerie to do that NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:46 PM
xx * I don't think so either. Michaela was guessing on that front too. Basically saying that it's a smart way to play it, but she's not really stating
krh5038
05/20/17 07:11 PM
xx * That may be true, but Sarah knew to let her hold the non-transferable advantage, and not her legacy advantage. NT
robin0
05/20/17 05:52 PM
xx * No one knows about the legacy advantage i believe...I'm sure Sarah does not want to show all her cards...Sarah can give the legacy after vote off. NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 06:10 PM
xx * That's my point. Sarah knew to give Cirie the non-transferable advantage to hold, not the legacy advantage that could be stolen. NT
robin0
05/21/17 04:42 PM
xx * To what end though? Cirie would be sure to read it after TC and see she was being set up. NT
JAF
05/20/17 03:54 PM
xx * It was not a setup as Cerie was never told to use it...Sarah never expected her to use it. NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 04:06 PM
xx * Cerie was just supposed to hold on to it and keep it if Sarah got voted out...Sarah wanted it back if she did not get voted out NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:57 PM
xx * Why? I don't see what sense that makes. Just holding it means nothing without the presumed ability to play it, which Cirie obviously thought
JAF
05/20/17 08:25 PM
xx * Cirie even told Sarah that she would give the advantage back to her after Tribal. Sarah was trying to pull Cirie away from Aubry so she gave Cirie
Hidef1080
05/20/17 11:03 PM
xx * It's what happened on the show...Sarah never told Cerie she could use it... She told her to hold it for this one vote incase she was voted out. NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 09:43 PM
xx * No, what I'm asking is what would be the point? I know that's what Sarah TOLD Cirie in the clip we saw, but it doesn't make sense unless she was
JAF
05/21/17 05:57 AM
xx * I wouldn't totally blame the editing. Due to CBS's schedule they had to cram two boots into one and this boot was the wrong one to do that. The more
Corndogger
05/20/17 02:50 PM
xx * I'm also not happy that Andrea's elimination was treated so flippantly. That seemed like a big deal in the overall narrative as she was a big presence
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 03:01 PM
xx * But then you have to assume Sarah had forgotten the rules to the advantage which I find very hard to believe. Sarah was testing Cirie and when Cirie
Corndogger
05/20/17 03:08 PM
xx * Sarah could also be giving the advantage to Cerie last minute for other reason other then she did not want Cerie to read it...
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:31 PM
xx * Yeah, exactly my point. It's difficult to just assume one thing there's a number of possibilities. NT
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 03:34 PM
xx * Not necessarily. If Sarah didn't expect anything to happen with the advantage there wouldn't have been a great need to explain every detail about it.
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 03:16 PM
xx * But how "good faith" is it if Cirie doesn't try to play it, then reads it as soon as she's in private after TC and sees it's non-transferable?
JAF
05/20/17 03:48 PM
xx * The good faith aspect of it is that Sarah wasn't going to use it. In line with this way of seeing it the idea is...
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 03:58 PM
xx * In other words your theory is that Sarah made a promise to Cirie not to use the advantage at all, and backed it up by giving the paper to her?
JAF
05/20/17 08:35 PM
xx * It's not my theory exactly, i'm still trying to figure out what happened... it's just one possible theory. It's not a promise it's in good faith.
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 09:58 PM
xx * Understood. I know we're all just speculating and trying to figure out what's a very confusing and seemingly illogical move that took place.
JAF
05/21/17 06:16 AM
xx * Sarah's true intention and thought process in all of this remains to be what's unclear, at least from how i'm interpreting things.
SpaceEVA
05/21/17 12:47 PM
xx * I just can't imagine Cirie not actually looking at it as soon as she gets a chance. NT
JAF
05/21/17 08:31 PM
xx * The thing is Sarah never gave it to Cerie to use or trick her.. it was just to hold incase she got voted out. Sarah read and knew what it said...
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:55 PM
xx * The rules didn't slip Sarah's mind. If she wasn't testing Cirie then why didn't she just tell her upfront that it was nonredeemable? NT
Corndogger
05/20/17 04:18 PM
xx * Why would she need to tell her anything?... Cerie was not supposed to use it, she was just going to hold it for this one vote....
RealityCK
05/20/17 04:44 PM
xx * To me that is a huge stretch. They've been making it a point to show us how perceptive Sarah is so for Sarah to forget the rules to something as
Corndogger
05/20/17 05:13 PM
xx * I'm not saying Sarah forgot the rules...She just in the moment ((Maybe)) did not realize that Cerie would not be able to use it after Sarah left.
RealityCK
05/20/17 05:23 PM
xx * I just can't imagine that anyone wouldn't think about it much and actually forget that it's non-transferable when she talked to Cirie about it.
JAF
05/20/17 08:43 PM
xx * I'm thinking Sarah was aware of the rules to the advantage but it just wasn't that big of a consideration to explain everything to Cirie.
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 05:40 PM
xx * If we're lucky the start of the next episode will show Cirie asking Sarah what happened and them providing us with some missing info. NT
Corndogger
05/20/17 03:26 PM
xx * I don't think it will be Cerie asking Sarah what happened... It will be Sarah asking Cerie to explain herself...not sure Sarah will believe her. NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:33 PM
xx * You don't think Cirie will ask Sarah why she voted for Michaela? Michaela was never mentioned by Sarah so Cirie will want to know why she switched
Corndogger
05/20/17 03:55 PM
xx * Sarah lost trust in Cerie because it appeared as if Cerie was betraying Sarah... So Sarah voted out Cerie's closest person in Micheala NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 04:00 PM
xx * Yes! Hopefully to start out the next episode they clearly show what happened in a flashback or convo between Sarah/Cirie or something. NT
SpaceEVA
05/20/17 03:33 PM
xx * The reason it was Michaela and not Cerie is as simple as Michaela can win immunity and Cerie can't... so you can vote out Cerie next week. NT
RealityCK
05/20/17 03:11 PM
xx * i know a lot are saying they didnt get why she went instead of Cirie but my first thought when her name was showing up in votes was exactly that. i
KlausHeissler
05/20/17 10:36 PM
xx * This is exactly why Michaela went...and not Cerie NT
SkyBluePink
05/20/17 08:44 PM
xx * Yep! NT
Axelsen
05/20/17 08:53 PM
xx * Yes, it repeats some of the stuff she said in the other interview but it's more definitive and further explained here. It confirms that Sarah knew
JAF
05/20/17 02:07 PM
xx * Thanks for the link. That makes more sense of the situation than we saw on the episode. I'm relieved it wasn't Aubry voted out. I'll always like
Blockhead
05/20/17 09:48 AM
xx * You are very welcome!Her explanation of how the vote went was great! NT
Mazita
05/20/17 09:51 AM

Extra information
Thread views: 7435
Thread Tags: None

Contact Us | Donate | Privacy statement | User List | Retired Forums | Acronyms and Board Terms | Report A Violation Home

*
UBB.threads™

Copyright 2023 JokersUpdates.com (v6.2x.Srv1)